The one thing you can often expect from Bildungsroman is little plot and that’s ok if the characters’ journeys are captivating enough to keep your attention from start to finish. I’m generally a fan of this genre (although I have a secret dislike for Catcher in the Rye – there, I’ve said it!), I’m a patient enough reader not to be troubled by the lack of “action” and I’m very happy witnessing characters develop, grow and learn about themselves. My Brilliant Friend, the first installment in Ferrante’s Neapolitan quartet, introduces us to Elena and Lila, friends from an early age, this book charts the ebb and flow of their connection as the girls endure the hardships of post-war Italy and how the social norms in their small community shape their lives and choices – all narrated by Elena.
The thing Ferrante excels at is the detailed and spot-on depiction of the intensity of women’s relationships; mother-daughter and girlfriends. Elena’s voice in this book, which ends when the girls are 16, was very reminiscent for me of that love/hate emotion and natural competitiveness that springs from close friendship during formative teen years; the realisation that your friend is brighter than you, more beautiful than you, expresses herself better, is more confident around boys, is all-round more popular and it pricks that oddest of mixed feelings, jealousy and admiration. It either spurs you on to be better or leads you to detest your friend. Elena feels all of these things towards Lila and sometimes we get a glimpse that Lila also feels jealous of Elena’s good fortune at being able to continue her education when Lila can’t.
Ferrante is not afraid of confronting ugly human behaviour and presenting it with shocking honesty. The complacent violence towards women and girls in this book is treated with accepted normality as is Elena’s first and unsolicited sexual experience at the hands of the father of a boy in her year at school, but perhaps more shocking to readers could be how Elena feels about and reflects on this episode.
Mostly though, this book is about two girls finding their way in life, making the best choices available to them from very few options in a neighbourhood governed by hierarchy, violence and tradition.
“Was it possible that only our neighbourhood was filled with conflicts and violence, while the rest of the city was radiant, benevolent?”
5 thoughts on “My Brilliant Friend – Elena Ferrante trans. Ann Goldstein”
I really enjoyed the whole series. It did take me a while to remember who all the characters were but it’s all part of the richness of the story.
You’ve captured the essence, I think! The cover may lead readers to expect a lighter story, but it’s quite dark. I have Books 3 & 4 to read still. Haven’t written my review of Books 1 & 2, but maybe never will…
Thanks! Keeping up with reviews is tricky for me too. Hence I am trying to write shorter punchier ones, but that’s not easy either if I’m honest – trying to decide what is important and will fit into 10 sentences or less!!!
I bought this for my mum and she enjoyed it though said it was difficult at first to remember who was who. Did yiu have that experience?
There are lots of characters, but very helpfully, Ferrante has added a list at the front for the reader to refer to when you have a confusing moment. I don’t think it’s helped by the fact that both Elena and Lila are known by different pet names to each other…